Skip to Content

Cookie Butter S’mores

A sweet and salty s'mores snack. Made with Ritz crackers, Trader Joe's Cookie Butter, marshmallows and chocolate chips. Made in a toaster oven. No fire needed s'mores!

I am not sure if I can call these S’mores but, I think with toasted marshmallows and chocolate it will make the cut. Since having a fire pit marshmallows have become a staple in my pantry. There are days when the S’mores craving strikes but, it is not feasible to go outside and build a fire. That is where my toaster oven comes in to save the day. I came up with this snack when the kids announced they wanted S’mores and so did I! I didn’t have the typical graham crackers or chocolate candy bars so I grabbed the next best things. This S’more is sweet, salty, buttery, chocolatey, and marshmallow happiness in your mouth!

The recipe below makes 3 S’mores. It can be easily doubled, tripled, quadrupled, etc.

0 from 0 votes

Cookie Butter S’mores


  • 6 Ritz Crackers
  • 21 chocolate morsels 6 to 7 morsels per S'more
  • 1 Tbsp Cookie Butter
  • 1 Marshmallow sliced into thirds.


  1. Lay out 6 crackers.
  2. Evenly spread Cookie Butter on 3 of the crackers.
  3. Place 6 to 7 chocolate morsels on top of the Cookie Buttered crackers.
  4. Place marshmallow slices on the remaining 3 crackers.
  5. Broil the 6 crackers in your toaster oven for 6 minutes. (Toaster oven cooking times can vary. Pull out when marshmallows are toasted brown)
  6. Let cool for a minute. The crackers will be very hot.
  7. Smash together creating 3 S'mores.


Assemble toaster oven S'mores

Yum! Right?


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.